#2

Good color. Good focus. Good lighting. Strong subject. Good contrast. Nice lines. Fills the frame. Well balanced.

#1 

Good Focus. Good light in back. Cluttered foreground. Edge mergers.

#4

Strong subject. Good color on boots. Nice angle, just need to be closer. Edge mergers.

#3

Strong subject. Out of focus. Very distracting background. Border left on the picture.