#3

Excellent focus, Excellent lighting, Fills the frame, Highlights in the eyes, Great appeal.

#2

Good focus, Plain background, Decent rule of thirds, Good catch lights, To much surrounding.

#4

Focus is good, Close-up, Lighting problem-both under & over exposed areas, See only one eye.

#1

Focus is good, Very distracting background, Mergers, Doesn't fill the frame, Puppy color is good, Bright colors distract.