#1

Good rule of 1/3's.  Fills the frame.  Leading lines take you to the action. Plain background. Strong Subject

#4

Good focus.  Nice framing.  Good leading lines.  Centered.  Over exposed in background and front.  Foreground a little distracting.

#3

Good rule of 1/3's.  Very Distracting Background clutters the picture.  Fills the Frame.

#2

Good range of tones.  Focus is good.   Doesn’t fill the frame. Many distractions.   Good idea, but is too stretched out.