#4

Good focus

Good lines leading your eye to the subject

Fills the frame

Good contrast

Good composition

Good exposure on subject areas

#3

Leading lines

Fills the frame

Nice contrast in rope and saddle horn

Rule of 1/3rds is well done

Same tonal colors

Focus is a little soft

#2

Interesting subject

Good focus

Too centered

Not enough contrast

Doesn't fill the frame

Some spots are overexposed

#1

Lamp is interesting

Centered

Out of focus

Grainy

Overexposed

Lacks contrast