#2

Good composition

Appealing subject

Nice contrast

Good focus

Good use of rule of 1/3rds

Paw is a leading line

Excellent detail

#4

Color is good

Strong eye appeal

Needs to pick up light in the eyes

A little centered

Change body angle

#1

Strong eye appeal

Good contrast

Bone is distracting

Too centered

Soft focus

Some spots are overexposed

#3

Focus is good on the subject

Light is good in the eyes

Some overexposure

Distracting background and foreground