#4

Vivid color

Good composition

Focus is good

Plain background

Good color

#2

Nice color

Excellent focus

Good texture

Good depth of field

Blemish on the picture

Close to being centered

Background mildly distracting

#1

Focus is good

Very distracting background

Doesn't fill the frame

Scratch on the picture

#3

Doesn't fill the frame

Focus is good on the subject

Background color makes a nice contrast

But there is way to much background