#2

Good rule of thirds

High horizon

Nice "S" curves

Good exposure & focus

Good depth of field

Creates a mood

#4

Good color & focus

Nice reflections

Good depth of field

Little busy

no definite focal point

Edge mergers

#3

Good color

Nice angles and lines

Soft focus

Lacks depth of field

Docks create a center line that weakens the photo

#1

Does not fill the frame

Lacks eye appeal

Good color

Has some hot spots

Edge mergers

Too much foreground